Steel 4140

Steel 4130 vs 4140: Differences and Selection Between Them

In the realm of alloy steels, two alloys stand out for their unique properties and widespread use: steel 4130 and steel 4140. These two commonly used steel alloys are low alloy steels in metal machining and possess properties with excellent strength, toughness, and corrosion resistance. Although 4130 and 4140 steel share some similarities, there are still significant differences that make them suitable for different applications. Understanding the differences between these two alloys is crucial for selecting the right material for your project. In this article, we delve into the detailed comparison of steel 4130 and steel 4140, exploring their key properties, applications, differences, and how to choose the right one for your specific needs.

What is Steel 4130?

4130 steel, also known as chromium-molybdenum steel, is a low-alloy steel with 0.3% carbon and contains other elements such as manganese, phosphorus, sulfur, silicon, chromium, and molybdenum. Compared to 4140 steel, it has a lower carbon content, which makes it ductile and easy to form, weldable, and shape. The 0.8-1.1% chromium content enhances its tensile strength, hardenability, and corrosion resistance, while 0.15-0.25% molybdenum boosts its strength, especially when heated. The properties of high strength, toughness, and excellent resistance to fatigue and corrosion make 4130 steel a preferred choice in industries such as aerospace, automotive, bicycle manufacturing, and other high-stress components. 

4130 Steel

Key Properties of Steel 4130

4130 is a chromium-molybdenum alloy steel, and it is widely used in various industrial applications due to its excellent mechanical properties. Here are some key properties of 4130 steel:

Good Weldability

4130 steel is weldable using conventional welding methods. It can be easily welded using techniques such as gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW), gas metal arc welding (GMAW), and shielded metal arc welding (SMAW).

High Tensile Strength

Steel 4130 exhibits a tensile strength of 97,000 psi, making it suitable for applications that require high strength-to-weight ratios and good impact resistance.

Excellent Toughness

This alloy possesses exceptional toughness, which allows it to withstand impact loads and resist fracture under stress.

Good Wear Resistance

The chromium content in 4130 steel provides good corrosion resistance, especially in mildly corrosive environments. However, for applications requiring higher corrosion resistance, additional protective coatings or surface treatments may be necessary.

Good Fatigue Resistance

4130 steel exhibits good fatigue resistance, making it suitable for applications subjected to cyclic loading or stress.

Good Machinability

4130 steel has good machinability, especially in the normalized or annealed condition. It can be machined using conventional machining processes such as drilling, milling, turning, and grinding.

High Elasticity

4130 steel exhibits high elasticity, boasting a yield strength of up to 63,000 psi. This indicates that the material can endure large amounts of strain and revert to its initial form.

Remarkable Ductility

4130 steel showcases remarkable ductility, especially when in its annealed condition. Consequently, this property facilitates drawing it into wires.

The Applications of Steel 4130

After undergoing various manufacturing processes like milling and welding, 4130 steel enables the production of a wide range of products in many applications. Some of the common applications include:

Automotive and Transportation: 4130 steel is widely used in the manufacture of automotive components such as suspension systems, axles, and driveshafts, where its strength and toughness are paramount.

Machinery and Equipment: The robustness of 4130 steel makes it a preferred choice for various machinery components, including gears, shafts, and structural components subjected to high stresses.

Aerospace and Defense: The aerospace and defense industries rely on 4130 steel for the production of landing gear components, airframe structures, and other critical components that demand exceptional strength and durability.

Tooling and Manufacturing: 4130 steel finds applications in the manufacturing of tools, dies, and molds, where its hardness and wear resistance are essential for prolonged service life.

Structural Components: Steel 4130 is employed in the construction of structural components for buildings, bridges, and other infrastructure projects.

Recreational Equipment: Its properties make it suitable for the fabrication of recreational equipment, such as bicycle frames, golf club shafts, and rock-climbing gear.

What is Steel 4140?

4140 steel is a low-alloy steel similar to 4130 steel. It contains a carbon content of 0.40% and other elements such as manganese, phosphorus, sulfur, silicon, chromium, and molybdenum. 4140 steel boasts a higher carbon content, which significantly influences its properties. This higher carbon content makes steel 4140 stronger and more durable, but slightly less weldable. With high tensile strength, excellent toughness, wear resistance, and fatigue strength, this steel alloy is a popular choice that requires extra toughness like crankshafts, gears, and high-strength bolts. Although 4140 steel retains good machinability despite its higher carbon content, extensive welding can pose challenges. Heat treatment of the parts is recommended to enhance weldability.

Key Properties of Steel 4140

Due to its properties, 4140 steel is applicable in rapid prototyping processes like CNC machining and sheet metal fabrication. Here are some key properties of 4140 steel:

Exceptional Tensile Strength and Fatigue Strength

Steel 4140 exhibits an impressive tensile strength of 148,000 psi and it is one of the strongest low-alloy steels. Its good fatigue strength makes it suitable for applications that involve cyclic loading or stress.

Excellent Hardness

4140 steel can be hardened to achieve high hardness levels. It can be heat treated to achieve a wide range of hardness values, making it suitable for applications that require a combination of hardness and toughness.

Good Wear Resistance

4140 steel exhibits good wear resistance, making it suitable for applications where the material is subjected to abrasive wear.

Good Corrosion Resistance

Like a lot of other steels, 4140 steel can rust. However, it is highly resistant to corrosion. Note that 4140 is not as corrosion-resistant as stainless steel. Proper coating or plating is often recommended to improve its corrosion resistance.

Good Machinability

While 4140 steel is harder to machine compared to some other alloys, it is still considered to have good machinability when heat-treated properly.

Good Weldability

4140 steel can be welded using conventional welding methods. However, preheating and post-weld heat treatment may be necessary to prevent cracking and ensure the desired mechanical properties.

Extreme Ductility

4140 steel is exceptionally ductile and easy to draw into wires. In addition, it exhibits good toughness and impact resistance, which enables it to withstand high loads without breaking or cracking.

4140 Steel Machined Part

The Applications of Steel 4140

Due to its superior strength and wear resistance, steel 4140 finds applications in various industries where durability and reliability are paramount. Some common applications include:

Heavy-duty Machinery: The superior strength and wear resistance of 4140 steel make it an ideal choice for components in heavy-duty machinery, such as construction equipment, mining machinery, and industrial presses.

Automotive Components: Steel 4140 is extensively used in the manufacture of critical automotive components such as crankshafts, connecting rods, and gears, where high strength and wear resistance are essential.

Transportation: In the transportation sector, 4140 steel is employed in the manufacture of railway components, truck axles, and other high-load-bearing applications that require exceptional durability.

Tooling and Cutting Tools: The hardness and wear resistance of 4140 steel render it suitable for the production of cutting tools, stamping dies, and other tooling components that endure significant wear and abrasion.

Structural Components: The high strength-to-weight ratio of 4140 steel has made it a desirable material for structural components in bridges, cranes, and other load-bearing structures.

Steel 4140 vs 4130: What are the Similarities?

Steel grades 4140 and 4130 are both low-alloy steels that share several similarities. Here are some of the key similarities between these two steel grades:

1. Composition: Both 4140 and 4130 are chromium-molybdenum steels, meaning they contain chromium and molybdenum as common alloying elements in addition to carbon. The composition of 4140 steel is approximately 0.40% carbon, 0.80-1.10% chromium, and 0.15-0.25% molybdenum. The composition of 4130 steel is similar, with approximately 0.30% carbon, 0.80-1.10% chromium, and 0.15-0.25% molybdenum. These compositions provide good strength, toughness, and wear resistance to both steels.

2. Heat Treatability: Both 4140 and 4130 steels are heat-treatable, which means they can be hardened and strengthened through heat treatment processes like quenching and tempering. This makes them suitable for applications that require high strength and wear resistance.

3. Mechanical Properties: When properly heat-treated, both 4140 and 4130 steels exhibit high tensile strength, yield strength, and hardness. They also have good toughness and fatigue resistance, making them suitable for applications involving cyclic loading.

4. Weldability: Both 4140 and 4130 steels are considered weldable, although precautions should be taken to avoid hydrogen-induced cracking and other welding-related issues.

5. Machinability: Steel 4140 and 4130 have good machinability properties, which means they can be easily machined using conventional methods.

6. Anti-Rust Property: Neither of the steel variants possesses anti-rust properties. Despite containing chromium like stainless steel, the amount present is insufficient to provide the desired anti-rust properties. As a result, both variants undergo heat treatments to enhance their stability.

7. Applications: Due to their similar properties, 4140 and 4130 steels are used in various applications that require high strength and wear resistance, such as shafts, gears, bearings, tools, and other industrial components.

While 4140 and 4130 steels share these similarities, there are some differences in their specific compositions and properties, which may make one grade more suitable for certain applications than the other. However, in general, they are considered to be part of the same family of low-alloy chromium-molybdenum steels and share many common characteristics.

Steel 4140 vs 4130: What are the Differences?

Although the similarities between 4130 and 4140 are mentioned above, there are some differences between the two in terms of their chemical composition, properties, etc. Below are the differences to consider in the 4140 vs 4130 steel comparison:

Steel 4140 vs 4130: Chemical Composition

Chemical Composition of Steel 4140 and 4130
41304140
Carbon0.30%0.40%
Manganese0.40-0.60%0.75-1.00%
Chromium0.80-1.10%0.80-1.10%
Molybdenum0.15-0.25%0.15-0.25%
Phosphorus0.035% (max)0.035% (max)
Sulfur0.040% (max)0.040% (max)
Silicon0.15%-0.35%0.15%-0.35%

As shown in the table above, the chemical compositions of 4140 and 4130 steel are similar aside from differences in carbon and manganese concentrations.

Steel 4140:

– Carbon: 0.40%

– Chromium: 0.80-1.10%

– Molybdenum: 0.15-0.25%

– Manganese: 0.75-1.00%

– Phosphorus: 0.035% (max)

– Sulfur: 0.040% (max)

– Silicon: 0.15%-0.35%

Steel 4130:

– Carbon: 0.30%

– Chromium: 0.80-1.10%

– Molybdenum: 0.15-0.25%

– Manganese: 0.40-0.60%

– Phosphorus: 0.035% (max)

– Sulfur: 0.040% (max)

– Silicon: 0.15%-0.35%

As you can see, the main distinction is the higher carbon content in 4140 steel, which makes it slightly harder and stronger than 4130.

Steel 4140 vs 4130: Properties

Mechanical Properties of Steel 4130 and 4140
41304140
Tensile Strength97,000 psi148,000 psi
Yield Strength63,000 psi95,000 psi
Elongation (2″)25.50%17.70%
Reduction in Area59.50%46.80%
Brinell Hardness197302

The following is the comparison of properties between steel 4140 and 4130, let’s look at that:

1. Hardness and Strength: Compared to 4130 steel, 4140 steel has a higher hardness, tensile strength, and yield strength. This makes 4140 more suitable for applications requiring higher strength and wear resistance. The tensile strength of 4140 steel is 148,000 psi, while the yield strength is 95,000 psi. On the other hand, the tensile strength of 4130 steel ranges is 97,000 psi, while the yield strength is 63,000 psi.

2. Toughness: 4130 steel is generally considered more ductile and tougher than 4140 steel, making it better suited for applications where impact resistance is crucial.

3. Hardenability: Both steels have good hardenability (the ability to form martensite during quenching), but 4140 has a slightly better hardenability due to its higher carbon content.

4. Weldability: Steel 4130 is more easily welded compared to 4140. It can be welded using common welding techniques, such as gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW) and gas metal arc welding (GMAW). Steel 4140 has a higher carbon content, which can lead to issues such as cracking during welding if proper precautions are not taken. Preheating and post-weld heat treatment are often required when welding 4140.

5. Machinability: With lower carbon content, 4130 steel is more machinable than 4140 steel. 4130 steel can be machined by using traditional techniques like drilling, milling, and turning and there is no risk of overheating or work hardening. In contrast, machining 4140 steel necessitates more machining procedures to prevent cracking.

6. Material Availability: 4140 steel is available in bar and plate form and is more cost-efficient. And 4130 steel is more commonly obtained in tube and sheet forms.

Steel 4140 vs 4130: Heat Treatment

4140 and 4130 steel can be subjected to heat treatment to enhance their characteristics, but they necessitate distinct heat treatment processes to attain the desired properties. 4140 steel undergoes quenching and tempering to achieve heightened strength and toughness.

In the hardening process, 4140 steel reaches a temperature ranging from 1600°F to 1650°F before being quenched in oil or water to reach a Rockwell hardness of 40-45 HRC. Subsequently, the steel is tempered at a temperature between 500°F and 600°F to enhance its toughness while preserving its hardness.

In contrast, 4130 steel is typically normalized and tempered to get similar properties. During normalization, the 4130 steel is heated to a temperature of approximately 1600°F to 1700°F before being air-cooled. This process aids in enhancing its strength and toughness.

heat treatment of steel

Steel 4140 vs 4130: Applications

4140 steel is commonly used in the manufacturing of high-strength components such as gears, shafts, studs, bolts, and other heavily loaded parts in the automotive, aerospace, and machinery industries. 4130 steel, on the other hand, is often used in applications that require a balance of strength and toughness, such as aircraft landing gear, suspension components, and structural components in the transportation and construction industries.

Steel 4140 vs 4130: Cost

The cost of 4140 and 4130 steel can vary depending on factors such as availability, market conditions, and the specific requirements of the application. In general, 4130 steel may be slightly more cost-effective than 4140 steel due to its lower chromium content. 4130 steel is an attractive choice for budget-conscious projects that still require good strength and toughness. For 4140 steel with superior strength properties, its increased cost may be justified in applications where its strength and hardness are indispensable.

How to Select the Right One Between Steel 4130 and 4140?

Choosing between Steel 4130 and Steel 4140 depends on the specific requirements of the application and the desired properties. Here are some factors to consider:

  • Strength Requirements: Applications that demand exceptional strength and load-bearing capabilities may favor the use of 4140 steel due to its higher tensile and yield strengths.
  • Wear Resistance Needs: If the application involves significant wear or abrasion, 4140 steel’s superior hardness and wear resistance make it a more suitable choice.
  • Toughness and Ductility Considerations: Applications that require a balance between strength and ductility, or those that involve impact loading, may benefit from the moderate toughness and ductility of 4130 steel.
  • Cost and Availability: While material properties are paramount, cost and availability may also influence the selection process, especially for large-scale or high-volume applications.
  • Manufacturability and Weldability: The ease of manufacturing processes, such as forming, machining, and welding, should be considered when selecting between 4130 and 4140 steel. In fabrication, where a lot of welding occurs, 4130  is a better choice because it has a lower carbon content than 4140. 
  • Heat Treatment Requirements: If uniform hardness distribution throughout the material is essential, Steel 4140’s better hardenability may be a deciding factor.

Summary

In conclusion, steel 4130 and 4140 are both exceptional alloy steels with distinct properties and applications. Understanding the differences and similarities between these two alloys is crucial in selecting the right material for your project. If the project requires high strength, toughness, moderate wear resistance, superior weldability, and formability, steel 4130 might be the better choice. On the other hand, if exceptional tensile strength, superior wear resistance, improved hardenability, and durability are paramount, Steel 4140 could be the way to go. The choice between the two ultimately depends on the specific requirements of your project. 

FAQs

Steel 4130 and 4140 are both chromoly steels, but they differ in their carbon content. Steel 4140 has a higher carbon content, making it stronger and more durable but slightly less weldable than Steel 4130.

Both 4130 and 4140 steel can be welded, but the higher carbon content in 4140 steel can present some challenges during the welding process. Proper welding techniques and procedures must be followed to ensure successful joining and minimize the risk of cracking or other defects.

Steel 4130 is commonly used in industries that require excellent weldability and formability, such as aerospace and automotive.

Steel 4140 is used in applications that require superior strength, durability, and abrasion resistance, like gears, axles, and high-stress parts in machinery.

On-demand Manufacturing Service

LEADRP provides prototyping and on-demand manufacturing services, including CNC machining, sheet metal fabrication, custom tooling, injection molding, urethane casting, and 3D printing. With LEADRP, you can solve any challenge throughout product development and manufacturing. Click to tell us about your project or contact us for more information.

From Design to Prototype
en_USEN
Table of Content
Scroll to Top

We make your custom products better and faster

Whether it's a one-off prototype made or a batch production of thousands, LEADRP is ready to support your project. Just tell us your project, and we will contact you within 12 hours.

All uploads are secure and confidential, click to check our IP Protection Policy. You can also contact us (service@leadrp.com) to sign a NDA before sending any design files to us. If it prompts that the file format does not support uploading, please compress the file into a zip file before sending it.